|
"By expanding
the scope of the statute's power to collect information on innocent people, the
Patriot Act failed to protect Americans' privacy," said the ACLU's Michelle
Richardson. "It has become painfully clear that unchecked Patriot Act power
inevitably leads to abuse, and National Security Letters are no exception.
Innocent Americans have been swept into investigations and recipients have been
barred from speaking about it publicly. Representatives Nadler and Flake should
be praised for the introduction of this bill and we urge swift action by
Congress to assure its passage."
Bill would limit 'overboard' Patriot
Act subpoena power
by Stephen C.
Webster
March 30, 2009
A
bipartisan bill introduced to Congress on Monday aims to curtail "overboard"
subpoena power given to federal authorities by the Patriot Act.
Congressmen Jerrold Nadler (D-NY) and Jeff Flake (R-AZ) said in a release that
National Security Letters, used by federal authorities to cull private
information such as Internet histories and financial records, have led to
"rampant abuse" and must be curbed.
"To ensure that Americans' privacy and free speech rights are protected, there
must be clear oversight and strict guidelines tied to the use of NSLs," said
Caroline Fredrickson, Director of the ACLU Washington Legislative Office, in an
advisory on Monday. "Mr. Nadler and Mr. Flake should be applauded for taking
this legislative step. Their bill will realign the current NSL authority with
the Constitution. Congress must take this opportunity to rein in the power of
the NSL."
"Government reports confirm that upwards of 50,000 of these secret record
demands go out each year,"
noted IPS News.
The ACLU's press release follows.
####
Congressmen Jerrold Nadler (D-NY) and Jeff Flake (R-AZ) introduced legislation
today to narrow the overbroad subpoena power in the National Security Letter (NSL)
provision of the Patriot Act. The bipartisan bill, National Security Letters
Reform Act of 2009, aims to curb rampant abuse of that power by federal law
enforcement following the expansion of the Patriot Act and was introduced with
17 cosponsors. NSLs are secret subpoenas used to demand personal customer
records from Internet Service Providers, financial institutions and credit
companies without prior court approval.
"To ensure that Americans' privacy and free speech rights are protected, there
must be clear oversight and strict guidelines tied to the use of NSLs," said
Caroline Fredrickson, Director of the ACLU Washington Legislative Office. "Mr.
Nadler and Mr. Flake should be applauded for taking this legislative step. Their
bill will realign the current NSL authority with the Constitution. Congress must
take this opportunity to rein in the power of the NSL."
NSLs were originally crafted to gain information about suspected terrorists but
the Patriot Act expanded the statute to allow the subpoenas, which are issued in
secrecy, do not require court review, and contain a gag order, to be used to
obtain personal information about people who are simply deemed "relevant" to an
investigation. After the statute's expansion, the Department of Justice's Office
of the Inspector General released a series of reports over the last several
years outlining systemic misuse and abuse of NSLs by FBI agents.
The ACLU is asking that Congress repeal the expanded NSL authorities that allow
the FBI to demand information about innocent people who are not the targets of
any investigation and reinstate prior standards limiting NSLs to information
about terrorism suspects and other agents of foreign powers. In December of
2008, as a result of an ACLU lawsuit, the gag order provision was struck down as
unconstitutional. The ACLU is now advocating that Congress legislate a
constitutional alternative. The National Security Letters Reform Act of 2009
would make these necessary changes.
Earlier this month, the ACLU released a report entitled "Reclaiming Patriotism"
that describes the widespread abuses that have occurred under the USA Patriot
Act. The report, authored by policy counsel Michael German and Richardson, was
delivered to congressional offices on Capitol Hill, as well as posted to the
newly re-launched site www.reformthepatriotact.org in anticipation of the
upcoming congressional debate surrounding three Patriot Act provisions due to
expire on December 31, 2009.

You can Comment at
Hearlink Blog
|